Purpose of this blog

Dmitry Yudo aka Overlord, jack of all trades
David Lister aka Listy, Freelancer and Volunteer

Sunday, March 8, 2015

The British 88?

A question I often see asked is "Why didn't the British use the 3.7" AA gun like the German 88?". By that they mean why not crank its elevation down to 0 degrees and start knocking out tanks. This is partially supported by Wikipedia's entry on the subject that reads:

"The 3.7″ was inherently unsuitable as an anti-tank gun. It was big and heavy, 2 tons heavier than the German 88, making it tactically unsuitable for use in forward areas. Additionally, heavy AA Regiments equipped with the 3.7″ gun were relatively few in number in the field army and controlled by Corps or Army HQ, or at even higher level HQs, and command of them was not often devolved to the commanders at Divisional level where the anti-tank role might be required."

The implication is that the 3.7" AA gun was only ever used in desperation before being overrun. As you might guess this isn't entirely true. Certainly pre-war, up until some time in 1938, crews were trained in direct fire roles. However the rapid re-arming of the British forces meant that this training was dropped. The mounts also had a part to play. With the MKI being a complex piece of equipment, the gunners faced forward. In the MKII (the static mount) the gunners were facing in towards the gun mount, and finally in the much simplified and lightened MKIII mount the gunners were facing towards the rear of the gun. 
 In the early years of the war the 3.7" did fight against German armour but not entirely successfully. In part this is because of the lack of suitable ammunition. In most cases they used a plugged shell, which is a shell with the fuse removed. At Boulogne the 2nd Heavy AA Regiment knocked out two attacking Panzers in this manner. Equally at Calais, at the Oyez farm four 3.7" AA guns of the 6th Heavy Anti-Air Regiment were dug in as part of the strong point. Two were sited to cover the wide open ground, and two were sited for AA work. The position was one of the last to be captured by the Germans, although some reports indicate the two forward guns sited for ground defence may have had to have been abandoned earlier, but they did take out several German tanks before being made unsuitable for use.

During and immediately after the Battle of Britain, defence of the home islands was on the minds of everyone. One of the worries was the new 100 ton tanks the Germans were thought to have. The answer was obvious, the 3.7" AA gun was about the only piece the British had that could dent these imagined monsters. So on the south coast a study was undertaken to find which beaches were suitable for landing these super heavy tanks, and several guns were sighted to deal with any landing.

But what to fire? Again here I can shed some light on another dark spot in the historical record. Up until now the only figure for penetration I've been able to find is from British & American Artillery of World War 2 by Ian V. Hogg. He gives a penetration figure of 117mm at 1000 yards against 30 degree sloped plate.

The quickest option was to make an semi-armour piercing round. This SAP round was an normal HE round with an armour piercing cap on top of it. Against a 30 degree slope this would go through 110mm at 400 yards and 94mm at 1000 yards. By July 1941 1000 rounds of SAP had been manufactured and shipped to the Middle East. However a full armour piercing round was under development at the same time. It was, unusually for the British, an AP round with a bursting charge. The British didn't tend to use bursting charges in AP rounds due to the chance of the charge being ejected from the shells base upon impact, making the hit ineffective. Its performance in the documents are 126mm at 400 yards and 115mm at 1000 yards, which tallies nicely with the previous figure. In total one third of a million of the AP rounds were manufactured.

The other innovation that came out of the invasion defence came from Birmingham. Under a plan codenamed "BARGAIN scheme" HAA units were tied into local artillery control and could be used to fire bombardments at pre-arranged targets. This did meet with some resistance from AA command as they pointed out that the high velocity would hamper indirect fire. However it was in this role the 3.7" was normally used throughout the war, where its long range was considered very useful.

Now what of that shipment to the middle east of ammunition? Well it may have first came into use in May 1942, when four guns were dispatched to the Knightsbridge Box at Gazala. The small size of the Box meant that only two guns were accepted into the position. These were set up, but ultimately didn't perform too well.


Things were different at Tobruk when in June German armour assaulted the line. Upon receiving warning of the attack the 3.7" crews dismantled the walls of their dug outs so they could depress their guns low enough. The German tanks were spotted at a range of 1500 yards, but before they could be taken under fire they entered dead ground. The dead ground led right up to the guns, meaning they'd next appear at a range of about 200 yards.
The gunners held their fire and waited. Then the Panzers appeared. The crews lept into action. With the gun barrel so low to the ground each blast kicked up a huge amount of dust, so it was difficult to see what was going on. However with a rate of fire of around twelve rounds per minute the guns laid down a fearsome barrage. In an engagement lasting two and a half hours the Germans were forced to retreat, losing six of eleven tanks that attacked the position.

Elsewhere in the desert the potential of the 3.7" was being tested with HAA units practising AT work at ranges filled with the hulks of knocked out Italian tanks or practising movements to form anti-tank screens. One particular exercise sounded very dangerous as the guns were not unlimbered first and were fired still on their wheeled carriages.

There is one other notable story from the war. During Operation Market Garden there are reports of a battle between Jagdpanthers and a HAA troop near the Town of Veghel, which the HAA troop won.

Image credits:

9 comments:

  1. Hello.
    I think that it is the American WW-I war, after made heavy cannon.
    Info: June 8 1940 in England was (only island armed forces) only
    420 light guns, and 163 heavy field guns,
    Ammo: only 200 rounds per gun, heavy 150 rounds per gun.
    (In addition, the 75 mm gun was turned in 1940 a good at-cannon)
    The home forces (in england) was home only 54 pc 40 mm anti-tank gun

    Roosevelt sent to English 500 000 rifles, 900 75 mm cannons, and 1,000 rounds per gun.
    The agreement "to pay for and transport" was valid (because the French had surrendered, the contract was (stayed) for the British)
    English merchant fleet to take care these guns transports.
    Then do not (yet) been a big submarine aiheuttaamaa problem.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Listy, have not received the award for the quiz competition. Should I put in a trouble ticket?

    ReplyDelete
  3. The girls here with us would never call you once your booking is over. This is one of the reasons why we here at the house ofCall Girls in Shimlahave earned ourselves a great reputation and a goodwill that is surely unmatchable. Check our other Services...
    Call Girls in Shimla
    Call Girls in Surat
    Call Girls in Surat
    Call Girls in Surat
    Call Girls in Surat
    Call Girls in Udaipur

    ReplyDelete

  4. Sexy Intelligent Hot Female Night Service In Best Hotels Pakistani escorts service in Lahore Top Dancer And Model 💃

    hi all friends call girls in Lahore I am madam dolly provided best VIP hot sexy new call girls in pakistan karachi lahore rawalpindi islamabad

    I love this Topic I serach this one for many time butt now i see this Lahore Escorts we offer you best Escorts service in Lahore
    Lahore Call girls +92 3053777077 Miss leena provider best vip escorts service in lahore.
    Escorts in Lahore is the best key word to search call girls in pakistani Lahore
    we serve best and VIP escorts in Islamabad also.
    call girls in pakistani Lahore
    pakistani call girls
    pakistani escorts service
    call girls in Lahore ❤️

    ReplyDelete
  5. if you want sexy and sweet girls from Lahore Escorts. Contact for best Escorts in Lahore, Lahore Escort, and VIP Call Girls in Lahore 03096711118. https://topescortslahore.com/

    ReplyDelete

  6. Escorts Service In Lahore Lahore call girls Escorts In Lahore Call girls in karachi

    hello...!! Good news for you we add some new girls in your Town (Lahore). we also have School and college going girls in Lahore.
    If you search Escorts Girls in Lahore you see my website on this website you found 20 girls in Lahore. Our girls are not typicl call girls in lahore. we also give you service in any hotel in Lahore.
    Escorts in Lahore is the bigest escorts service in Lahore
    Lahore Escorts
    Elite Lahore Escorts
    Call girls in Lahore

    Best Vip Full Hot Sex New Models escorts in lahore service in good hotel ✅
    Real Escort Service In Pakistan Lahore Islamabad And escorts service in lahore Karachi Rawalpindi
    Corona Free Girls Available In Hotel Service ( Baba Ji +92-305-3333-758 Call Now And On WhatsApp Mobile Number 📞 ) Call girls lahore Best Vip Call Girls Provider Anytime Contact Real Person
    well educated neat and clean Cooperative staff in Pakistan full hot sex call girls 👙 call girls in Pakistan Lahore
    One Of The Well known escorts Office in Lahore, Lahore is capital and heart of Punjab. It is exceptionally popular for business of escorts. Various people come here for various

    ………… /´¯/) click for supper hot and sexy top luxury escort Service girls in lahore ❣️
    ……….,/¯../ /
    ………/…./ /
    …./´¯/’…’/´¯¯.`•¸
    /’/…/…./…..:^.¨¯\
    (‘(…´…´…. ¯_/’…’/
    \……………..’…../
    ..\’…\………. _.•´
    …\…………..(
    ….\…………..\.

    ReplyDelete