Some 10651 (!) players took part in the most recent poll (there was support for this poll on both forums, so no wonder :) ). 63% (6720 voters) voiced there strong feeling that the number of SPGs per team should be limited somehow, while 22% of players have no issues with the concept of SPGs and existing balance, 9% still don't like the way arty works in-game, and 6% think that it is OP.
Thanks for the feedback, it will take time, but the issue will be addressed.
As always new weekly poll is up (this time - just for fun).
Thanks for the feedback, it will take time, but the issue will be addressed.
As always new weekly poll is up (this time - just for fun).
Yeah I've found both playing arty and not being arty that two seems to be the magic number. 3 is tolerable more is just annoying.
ReplyDeleteI hope this was not for nothing....
ReplyDelete(Voted to limit the number of SPGs per team)
((would have also voted its OP if there were two options....))
Beta experienced player with 6k+ battles.
Cheers Kowabonga
Will the tracers come back some day?
ReplyDeleteSometimes you have 4 SPG`s, sometimes 1 and sometimes no. For me the balancing in WoT is perfect. I don`t want to have matches with limitations. I love the unexpected !
ReplyDeleteThanks Overlord. Glad to hear that we can expect a positive change in the artillery aspect of this game. 5-6 top tier arty on each team is a real bummer. Looking forward to all the changes coming up in WoT. Keep up the good work!
ReplyDeleteAgreed, it should be generally limited to 2 with occasionally 3 per side, per match, but no more than that. Having 4 or more artillery per side is a problem.
ReplyDeletearty is not a big problem, its just when all tanks are gone and there are 5 arty camping in each base waiting for nothing :P
ReplyDeleteI play world of tanks only for CW.
ReplyDeleteBecause this game is boooooooring for me after 1.5 years of playing.
For those 6% that thinks arty is OP... abandon tanks and play arty only and you will rule...
ReplyDeleteYes, must agree - from both an arty drive and a TD driver viewpoint, 3 or less is good.
ReplyDeleteI played a map that had 5 arty a side, that was horrid.
i voted for some kind of limitations on SPG, however, if tracers were to be reintroduced i think the problem would solve itself.
ReplyDeletejust fix the tracer problem and arty will be less effective, not much but still good enough. i miss those days where arty spend a few minutes at the start of match to counter battery.
ReplyDeleteI'm a fan of the game but not the customer support. Waiting 48hrs inbetween replies only to get standard replies is very poor.
ReplyDeleteA limitation is a must in my opinion. Yesterday i had a game with me e-100 in a platoon with another e-100 and a Maus, map was capinovca with 8 artys per side!!! so with a total of 30 vehicles you had 16 Artys there and no hummel it was t8+9.
ReplyDeleteA limitation like the ones for companys would be nice lets say a battle has a max of 15 Points for arty so you could see as maxed 1x t9 and 1x t6 on a side would be totally enough in my eyes.
Arty as it is right now just kills the game.
there- their
ReplyDeletehttp://kepkezelo.com/images/6lp0rh8hz981ktmeruyw.jpg
ReplyDeleteJust 3 arty per side, nice old times.... :D
/dramatisation on
ReplyDeleteOh frag, 6 SPGs per side!! omgomg we're doomed!
http://img822.imageshack.us/img822/8788/shot294f.jpg
not really, guess what happened?
http://img594.imageshack.us/img594/1501/shot293.jpg
/dramatisation off
It's ok, you just have to adapt.
limit to 2-3 max or tracers back
ReplyDeleteQ: I'm a fan of the game but not the customer support. Waiting 48hrs inbetween replies only to get standard replies is very poor.
ReplyDeleteA: 48h is much indeed. Must be either an exceptional case or a sort of failure.
Q: Is there any chance that there will be an limitation of 2 spg´s at each site?or what are your plans?
ReplyDeleteI think an platoon of 3 spg´s is too strong. There will be no dynamic in the match, because every spoted tank will be killed in a few seconds.
Actually, there have been hundreds of topics and posts on the forum regarding the arty issue, so it isn't a surprise at all. Hope you will implement a limit, though.
ReplyDeleteThx for this poll. 2-3 arties on public are OK. If you play clan wars it is really different and arties are really important. So for CW do not limit number of arties per game, please.
ReplyDelete> Overlord: customer support replied me really fast but it seems that they are like bots and they just copy answers. This is really annoying. And if you reply again, the message always cannot be delivered.
Too many matches for me end in a stalemate between 4/5 arty pieces each side. When I see 5 arty on the opposing side it really takes the enjoyment out of the game, you just know that as soon as you get spotted all hell breaks loose and your dead before you know it. I much prefer the tank only battles. Arty has it's place for sure, but more than 2 it's no fun at all
ReplyDeleteI think arty is just fine: here's a hint, I prefer light and medium tanks.
ReplyDeleteIf arty is going to be limited heavies need a limit as well.
Number of artilleries is not a problem, it is just matter of playing style between no arty and 3+ / side. Just like you have to adapt with mid-tier medium. Once you are strongest tank on your team and next you are no more than weak scout.
ReplyDeleteI see one issue here: the epic medal awarded for destroying 5 SPGs in game (Burda's Medal). If the number is limited then this achievements should be changed as well. I, for one, have seen only once, in 3000+ games, more then 4 SPGs in one team.
ReplyDelete> Lord Azaghul: This is not truth. If you get tracked you have 5 seconds of live remaining ;)
ReplyDeleteI agree with Lord Azaghul. The complaints about arty are totally out of the way. If you are annoyed by arty then you will be annoyed by the number of hevys after this arty "problem" is sorted out.
ReplyDeleteLets not get to the point when everything I am not playing with is OP and think a little about your play stile.
The problem with too many arty for people is they dont know how to play from cover and love to be out in the open, sitting to fire. Players should learn more to be a total team player and go for the win as a whole. Not trying to get all the kills themselves and use arty to the advantage and spot for them instead of crying about them.
ReplyDelete" I love the unexpected !"
ReplyDeleteA brick in ya face is unexpected too... :D
Limited limitations should avoid the 6 vs. 7 arty battles in the game.
> Thultarn: Sure, but you can use this only in clanwars. Not in public games. There is no way to coordinate all the players in your team. And many of them play like trolls, lemmings etc..
ReplyDeleteHans_von_Luck said...
ReplyDeleteQ: Is there any chance that there will be an limitation of 2 spg´s at each site?or what are your plans?
I think an platoon of 3 spg´s is too strong. There will be no dynamic in the match, because every spoted tank will be killed in a few seconds.
Unquote
Limiting arties to 3 per team is way easier to make than 2. Otherwise, when creating a platoon of three, all three wouldn't be allowed to pick arty. It would require more programming than just putting the right platoons together in the matchmaker.
hey overlord , i think that having 3/4x arty per team is not the problem , its rather ok , it makes it a hard game , no mistakes allowd, problem that tank is rather easy for anyone to play and it has too much damage , tier 7 arty was ovp and you guys cooked the t8 arty where they can 1 shot 1 tier 10 .. that doesnt seem really ok , i dunno why you ppl did that , no offense; nerf them please ... even having two arty in game , if they t92s for example and shoot near you .. you prolly die .. uncool, this was my point .. it just equals that arty is ovp in my opinion.
ReplyDeletecheers
jarod , european server.
Arty is fine... as long as it isn't 5-6 on Malinovka... Think you shouldn't have more than 5, so that a "super-platoon" can be full arty. But when you have 6+ and just one is T5 the rest is over. Then it's OP.
ReplyDelete15 members in each team.
ReplyDelete5 classes of tanks
3 would be the perfect number of limitation
> jarod: You can 1-shot everyone. I have T8 arty and I usually do 800 - 1000 dmg to any tank. If you 1-shot someone, it has to be a really great shot. But this can happen with standard tank too if you hit ammo.
ReplyDeleteEvery day I am playing there will be 3-5 matches with more than 4 SPGs.
ReplyDeleteI want to play your game,because there will be not so many SPGs ;-)
Style of playing?The only thing what is usefull in a match with more than 3 SPGs is to camp.
Standing 10min behind a house or something like that, there will be no fun.
In answer to the new poll: I play WOT because I enjoy Clan Wars. Random battles are mostly boring now, I've played for about 5 months.
ReplyDeleteI play only to get the "daily doubles" and sometimes in clan wars. It's only because i played lots of matches where people just couldn't do anything even with their tier 9-10 tanks. I don't say that tier 10 tanks are gods, but i think those who get these top tanks should've learned how to play while grinding for them. With this, i mean suicidal scouting IS-7s, Mauses going on the open field with 3 arties in the enemy team, and those T30s who think their armor is unpenetrable.
ReplyDeleteSo because of the number of these players, i play something else to relax and have fun. But as i said it's not the game's fault.
About the arty problem: I voted for limiting the number per side. As a tank, you don't want to be raped in the first minute of the match. As an arty, you want to get damage and exp too, but it's harder when everyone is shot down before you can "lock on" to the target. Not to mention that everyone will blame you because you don't have 25 kills in a single battle.
That's all, good luck everyone and have fun :)
http://kepkezelo.com/images/6lp0rh8hz981ktmeruyw.jpg
ReplyDeleteQ: This is playable for heavy tank?
Q: Are tracers for hidden vehicles considered to be re-implemented in the game at some point in the future? I think that will resolve the issues that most people have with artillery and make the game more enjoyable to play again.
ReplyDeleteIn reply to the style of play comments. Being safe from arty can be fun if your not sure that they are going to shoot at you. If there is 5 arty a side then they are almost certainly going to shoot at you. Which means staying behind something for the entire match wee.
ReplyDeleteAs arty its boring as to because you have to hope your shells travel faster than your fellow arty so you get kills unless there whole team is lit up at the same time. Plus running out of tanks to spot for you makes for very kamikaze style play.
Still fow what was this poll?WG dont care about option from people.63% want limit arty and gues what wg change nothink and you will still meet 6+arty per team
ReplyDeleteOverlord,
ReplyDeletewhen speaking of strong and unbalanced arty, two question arise:
1. Are tracers planned to be back in 0.7.0?
2. Do you consider an arty limit in random battles?
Thank you.
this is world of tanks but not world of laser guided satellite view arties. The poll already said majority of players are not happy with the arty situation. please bring back the tracer or limit arty to 2/3 per sides.
ReplyDeletethose are the fun games X.x :
ReplyDeletehttp://imageshack.us/f/851/shot261.jpg/
Adapt? Only way for heavy or TD to adapt in match with 4+ artys in team is camp hard. True heavy killer should be TDs, I bet that T95 with Object can control heavies and not frustrating them with "god of hand" even if they're shooting from bushes cause you have more areas obscured from their fire.
ReplyDeleteSo limit will be fine, but for current arty firepower I would nerf range also.
15 members in each team.
ReplyDelete5 classes of tanks
3 would be the perfect number of limitation
This is the perfect math as stated above. Also it would not hinder the possibility a platoon to choose all arty. 3 arty in same platoon is a game changer from my experiences, but goddamn I still love doing it.
I voted that artillery should be limited, cause I figured voting that artillery is overpowered would not accomplish anything.
ReplyDeleteHowever I do think artillery is overpowered as well, they do too much damage.
I remember back in beta before Tier 7 artillery got released they explained that the reason Tier 6 arty was so powerful was cause they were balanced to fight top tier tanks and they would be nerfed when higher tier arty was added.
...and so they were, however not in the way expected. I figured they would lower damage for tier 6 artillery but no, they just reduced their accuracy and perhaps rate of fire (don't remember anymore). Meanwhile tier 7 and 8 got even more absurd damage or faster rate of fire.
Artillery hit too hard, kill too many crew members/modules etc, that's the problem. Their damage should be lowered and so should the radius of the splash damage. Then their accuracy and ROF can be buffed to compensate.
Pls OVERLORD. as many other posters stated, dont MISINTERPRET the poll results !!!
ReplyDeleteMe, as many others, have voted for "Limiting...", but i and many others have further GENERAL issues with HIGH-Tier-Artys especially:
1. We think, they are OP, especially the SPLAH-DAMAGE (the splash-damage itsself and the radius of splash aswell), making it too EASY to hit everything, destroying Light Tanks by a near miss, crippling Mediums to death and even HT dont find many obstacles big enough to be completly safe...
2. Many people dont also like the current way, SPGs are introduced in game !! Instead ob being a high-precise sniper, many of us would like to see it more in a rapid-firing aerial bombarding supporting role !! But we dont believe this concept would get ever implemented...
So pls, DONT interpret this poll like 84 % having no issues with Arty itsself... its more like only 22% having no issues with Artys, the rest have MANY issues, but your poll had allowed only ONE choice...
So many of my fellows think:
- LIMIT splash-DAMAGE and-RADIUS of High-Tier-Artys
- LIMIT the amount of High-Tier-Artys per side to a max of TWO or THREE Artys, if lower Tiers are involved
THREE High-Tier-Artys are dominating the battlefield as much as 6 or 7 do...
Best regards
I play World of tanks cause there are no other good games out atm. I'm bored of WoW and diablo 3, torchlight 2 etc are still months away. Once some good online games are released I'm done with World of Tanks. It's getting boring playing tank death match over and over again.
ReplyDeleteI personnaly find loading into a pub match in my is4 only to see 2 t92 2 object 261 and a lone gwtiger less than pleasurable. At that point in time I just bend over and take the loss of credits and move on
ReplyDeleteDang, I missed this poll.
ReplyDeleteI think arty is a good aspect of the game, however, when I'm in my T34 (1900 hp) and there are five tier 8&9 arty (1700-2500 avg damage) on each team it is insane then through in some faster firing lower tier and you are dead before you have a chance to do anything about it. I know they have a longer reload time, but when they do near +75% damage in a single hit and usually track the tank in the same hit, you have 2-3 more shells coming in from the others now or there are a few snipers set up just waiting for the opportunity. I have seen and had this happen to me far too often especially on Malinovka and El Halluf.
I am all for regulating arty in a number vs tier scheme and perhaps even removing them from some maps.
"I'm a fun of online games"
ReplyDeleteI think you mean "fan" :P
I have no probs with arty. Like stated before one has improvise and addept ingame. Thats the exciting point in the game. It happened to me several times that arty had a pick on me and blew me to pieces. Next time better (its just a (marvelous) game)!
ReplyDeleteEveryone knows deep inside, that they play WoT to watch Ola during the newscast ;)
ReplyDeleteJust remove the high tier artys 6+ and bring in Katyusha rockets with a 1 strike only carpet hit maybee with 1 tier 5 arty supporting ;) that`ll change the gameplay abit eh :):)And wid be really class tae watch tae :)
ReplyDeleteread it plz: (+1 !)
ReplyDelete------------------
Anonymous said...
Pls OVERLORD. as many other posters stated, dont MISINTERPRET the poll results !!!
1. We think, they are OP, especially the SPLAH-DAMAGE (the splash-damage itsself and the radius of splash aswell), making it too EASY to hit everything, destroying Light Tanks by a near miss, crippling Mediums to death and even HT dont find many obstacles big enough to be completly safe...
2. Many people dont also like the current way, SPGs are introduced in game !! Instead ob being a high-precise sniper, many of us would like to see it more in a rapid-firing aerial bombarding supporting role !! But we dont believe this concept would get ever implemented...
So pls, DONT interpret this poll like 84 % having no issues with Arty itsself... its more like only 22% having no issues with Artys, the rest have MANY issues, but your poll had allowed only ONE choice...
So many of my fellows think:
- LIMIT splash-DAMAGE and-RADIUS of High-Tier-Artys
- LIMIT the amount of High-Tier-Artys per side to a max of TWO or THREE Artys, if lower Tiers are involved
THREE High-Tier-Artys are dominating the battlefield as much as 6 or 7 do...
written at:
September 14, 2011 4:37 PM
-----------------
Recommended!
Sincerely
C'mon guys, more than 3 artys per side is very rare. I like when it happen sometimes cuz its a nice diversity of boring grind.
ReplyDeleteOverlord, can you give us some informations about the reintroduction of the tracers? I can´t hardly understand what the problem could be. When they were deactivated it was scheduled to activate them with the next patch (it was 6.4 I guess) or a hotfix. As so many people (~300) work on WoT I can´t understand why it takes so long, even it hasn´t a great priority.
ReplyDeleteFor me current arty is good but limitation on arties per battle would be even better.
ReplyDeleteHowever a more interesting concept for arty would be this:
Increase rate of fire and ammo capacity significantly .
Make arty very inaccurate.
After each shot on the same target accuracy would increase , unless target is in site range then accuracy would be good from the start.
This would be a bit more realistic as there does exist arty ranging .
It would also make the game more fun as you would see explosions all around you getting closer and close as the arty zeroes in.
I played this game since the closed beta. The idea was perfect and this game is still uniqe in his style. I spend lot of money in this, but now i play the game only when CW is comming up at evning. You guys leading this game in a very very wrong direction, and you take my mood from the game. Its not worthing my time anymore.....
ReplyDeletewell if we bring up SPGs then next should be TDs hell the other day there were 10 on one team and 2 on the other... you know which win.. so maybe look at that next
ReplyDeleteVictory!
ReplyDeleteExperience: 10651 (!) doubled for the first
victory of the day
Credits: to all who voted!
Attacking:!
NO M103? DUMB POLL AGAIN!
ReplyDeleteReintroducing tracers = insta-dead arty + hacks
ReplyDeleteReducing arty accuracy = arty becomes worthless
Limit arty to 2 or 3 = heavies strongly dominate the game.
Remove/reduce splash damage = arty bounces - team calls arty players noobs, nobody plays arty
This isn't about realism its about game play.
This game is VERY much rock/paper/scissors/lizard/spock.
Everyone wants what they play to win most of the time - currently most of the higher tiers are heavies.
- what's the easiest thing to use in the game = heavies
-what players have the most problem with arty = heavy plaers...because arty is the ONLY 1 to 1 heavy counter.
Most med's have to wolf pack, lights can't kill heavies. Only other heavies and arty can kill heavies, and everything can kill arty!
I think this works fine.
Please don't hard cap arty at 2 or 3 unless you hard cap heavies - that WILL hurt the game...but I have a feeling the devs know that!
Question for Overlord
ReplyDeleteQuestion for Overlord
Q. Are there any plans to increase the maximum speed of the T28 and T29?
^^^ I meant T28 and T95
ReplyDelete>paramel So basically we punish players using arty because people cant use common sense? We punish arty because players dont want to be a team player? Even tho you cant communicate in game fast it shouldnt matter each match is about winning period, those that cant understand that arent and never will be a team player and it is most of them that are crying about the use of arty. They are the ones that hate to have to hide from arty and not just race to the flag.
ReplyDeleteI play arty too, if it is more than three arty on map, then they destroy each other's game too.
ReplyDeleteI think there should be max of 4 artys per side unless its clan wars then its all fair gain dont limit that one
ReplyDelete@Lord Azaghul
ReplyDeleteIf you are able to play this game it is of course possible to kill a heavy tank with an medium tank.
I can give you many excamples that 2 or 3 SPGs are enough that heavys did not dominate anything.
Which game are you playing?
lol @ all fail arty trolls
ReplyDelete>Lord Azaghul, your retarded, EVERYTHING you wrote there is a bull of shit (lol)
arty is clearly op at high tier matches and heavies are very easy to kill unless your a 12 year old dumbass in t29 trying to 1v1 an is-4 and shooting right at the frontal armor
also, speaking as both a heavy and arty player so there is no bias to this, even in an Object 212 I find it too easy to kill anything
-reduce damage
-reduce splash range
-reduce splash damage
-limit arty to 2 per side (3 for lower tiers)
-release more "town" maps
I forgot something.
ReplyDeleteThe easiest thing to use in game is arty. You did not need much skill to be usefull.
Arty could be good. The only problem is, that they are "free to shoot". If the tracers would be back in the game, they won't be OP any more.
ReplyDeleteThis whole problem started after traces had been switched off. How many times we have heard that creating new traces systems is Wargaming priority? For a few months you are clearly aware of arty problem , but nothing has been done so far. There seems to be time to fix gun mantles look ( LOL & WTF?? ), but fundamental element of this game has been broken for so long and no wonder that 63% of players would like to see some sort of limit for arty. A few new light tanks may help, but won't fix this problem completely. Fix the tracers system and arty issue will be resolved. In all of these recent patches we see only bloody bodging.
ReplyDeleteI can only assume the nay-sayers only know how to play heavies!
ReplyDeleteHeavies are the most forgiving tank type in the game.
Arty is the ONLY thing that heavies have to concerned about.
Yes meds CAN kill heavies. But tank for tank same tier - that heavy probably has the advantage. Most maps allow heavies to funnel everything to their front armour. Heavy players whine because arty is the ONLY thing that gets around this EASILY, and even that is VERY map dependent!
Arty isn't even close to being OP.
Most players just seem to misunderstand the roll of arty. Arty is support - and unlike heavies, arty can't win the game on their own. So if arty is reliant on OTHER TEAM MEMBERS, how does that make them OP for game play? Because they have a big gun? Um, that's ALL that they are = a big gun. You nerf the big gun - no more arty. The game become WORLD OF HEAVY TANKS.
PS if you're going to insult me - at least attach your profile to your comment!
-theghostcat
us server
I chose other, and here's why:
ReplyDeleteI would have checked all the options before, but not anymore. As you devs didn't get your priorities right, and went off expanding into 2 other IPs, you left us rot here with 1 game mode for a year. This is ridiculous.
Next up is that you guys don't listen to your player base nearly as much as you should. Are you making a game for yourselves, or for others? Then listen to the people. Just like this arty thing. This has been going on now since the game was released basically, and it's never been addressed, and your tweaks were non-sense. I think it's pretty evident that until you can come up with a proper way to make arty work you need to limit the number of them to 2-3 max (2 Tier 7-8).
Your elementary manner of "balancing" is ridiculous, with W/L% and such. What's even better is that for example the JTiger has been on the losing end of the stick since day one and you haven't done anything besides pointless "fixes" that accomplished nothing, in which you still didn't follow up on.
Biased. You guys are biased. Just come out and admit it already. Like the JTiger shows along with the IS-4 getting a free ride on the OP-train now since launch without balancing nerfs, we know you're biased period.
Camo system. Get rid of it. It's what is most likely causing all the "disappearing tanks" non-sense. But you won't get rid of it, and we all know why. The bias. Because then russian tanks would lose another edge they have (inflated camo ratings) over the high tier US and German tanks.
So yeah, my "Other" is actually; I used to love the game until I realized all these issues. Now I'm fed up with it, and don't give you guys any more money until you guys respect us and take the consumer seriously. And guess what, if this game isn't fixed, then I won't be putting money into your other games neither. So that's nearly $300 lost right there, per game.
Oh, and I almost forgot. That "Pre-order" fiasco. BS. You really shown us your true colors there. If this post is deleted like my others that mentioned about this "pre-order" stuff, I'm going to complain to Gamestop and other retailers about what you did, thus next time they won't give you guys any shelf space at all.
And Overlord. Disabling comments. It's called Freedom of Speech. We're used to it, unlike you. PEACE.
this is a picture from a game I played today 14.09.2011
ReplyDeletehttp://i260.photobucket.com/albums/ii12/Creohan/shot_007.jpg
enjoy!
PS: game was very fast
Lord Azaghul AKA the scary "theghostcat":
ReplyDeleteYou have been proven to show no knowledge what so ever before, and by looking at your statistics, once again you still don't know enough about the game. So ride the pine kid, and don't talk with "authority" on anything, because you can't. You should just worry about becoming a better player yourself first, and experience the entire game. Until then, no one will take you seriously. Just saying.
I did not insult anybody and you can read my ingame name (eu) at beginning of my post.
ReplyDeleteI am sure that arty at its own can win a game.
It is true that arty use other team mates, but only for spoting enemy tanks.
I give an excample:
http://www.bilder-space.de/show_img.php?img=ad56ac-1316019132.jpg&size=original
I also think insulting other players for there opinion is not usefull.
ReplyDeletePost your ingame name at beginning and do not write under anonymous.
Dear Overlord,
ReplyDeleteI'm a lot time player, have been playing since close beta testing. And I bought lot of pre when release too. For the last 2months I was busy and didn't play any. I just came back in the last few days and I was so disapointed. You release the E100, which has same gun and T30, but better amored and even more HP. Now my T30 is useless and and my clan all pick E100 instead of T30.
I wonder wth you guys thinking. You can't balance the whole tech trees but just simple few tier 10 and you f* it up!
I feel I wasted my money in this game and very disapointed. WOP come out and I may play for the fun of it, but you can count on me when I say I will not waste a dime like i did with this f*ing game.
Regards,
I'm a bit of a tank freak (buff??), a fan (fun?) of MMOs and I love this game as well as I like to play it to relax after work (also video game QA ;)
ReplyDeleteBTW, for constructive feedback it is better to actually read longer player opinions than to rely on polls, but still, it is really awesome you publish every poll results and have some really bold polls, like the Komarin one on EU.
I am personally fine with 3 arties per team, if only I could see by the tracers from which side are they shelling me. Different playstyles for games with and without arty give some nice diversity.
Funny how mostly SPG players get mad about it. And thats the 20% of the poll votes that says theres nothing wrong with it. And to Mr.Azaghul, for the HT hunting there is TD's and other HT's and your precius SPG's should be mostly countering other arty and providing suport fire, not the longrange tankbuster. Especialy when theres 10x T6+ SPG's in game and if theyre fags with gold HE ammo.
ReplyDeleteBTW wheres the tracers?! Without them theres no reason to buy obj.212 as counter arty... Favorite discipline of many players :)
Everyone in the game complains for the existence and not only the number of artillery...you should rename your project world of arties....
ReplyDeleteBesides the artillery crap isnt the only problem...the "cooked" balance that you have (so to keep random statistics 50-50) is the biggest online "trick" (arent laws for these maybe?) i have ever seen.
Continue your good work....you will soon discover that once fool=never again...
3 arty max ..
ReplyDeleteArty definitely needs to be addressed. For the record, I have over 7500 battles, play every branch (many to their maximum tier) in the tech trees including arty. I am not bragging, just stating I have a lot of WOT experience.
ReplyDeleteFew things to say...
To those that say they rarely see more than 3-4 arty in a game, I'm not sure what game you play, because I see it frequently during my gaming sessions every single day(I put an inordinate amount of my time into this game).
To those that say you need to adapt to a lot of arty I say BS. Sometimes you just can't camp in a bush all game. Sometimes the enemy is pushing and you HAVE to get in the fight knowing your gonna be exposed to a lot of arty fire. If your tier 9 or 10 that means you get to die first and usually right away.
As an arty player I hate having a lot on each team, because when a tank gets tracked and 5 arty fire at it, it reduces my chance for the kill, and to gain XP. More hits for me = more XP, more arty = less hits since everything is killed fast. So in the end 7 arty on a team hurts my xp/cred gains AS an arty. Plus you have less tanks out in the field fighting, which leaves gaps in defenses and means less targets for me to shoot at as arty(games feel sluggish and slow).
To those that said it would become world of heavy tanks. It already is! Most tanks I see are HT's as they are the main battle tanks. TD's are supposed to be the main counter to HT's and work to great effect, not to mention of course other HT's and wolfpacks of MT's.
I am an arty player and I think there needs to be a limit and perhaps a nerf, though we need to bring back tracers and try it out before a nerf. For now at least a limit would be great as 2-3 per game is honestly a perfect number.
"Thanks for the feedback, it will take time, but the issue will be addressed."
ReplyDeletewhat has WG then done all that time, this is an isseu already known in the mid of the Beta time.... just like tiered tank companies etc etc. i have the feeling WG doesnt do much with the info provided by players.
but anyway, good its adressed now and perhaps we will see a resuld in the end of 2012 i pressume.
my personel opinion, maby offcard arty strike over an area is an idea, ore els atleast limit it to 2 units a team. at now in lowtier battles its 1 shotted by arty all the time, and in higher tiers the class 7/8 does massive damage, especialy with 5+ of those in one team! i think its a failure to add tier 8 arty to the game.
@Current Poll (Other reason (specify in comments)):
ReplyDeletePlaying with roommates - itsa good team-playing game.
Lord Azaghul AKA the scary "theghostcat":
ReplyDeleteYou have been proven to show no knowledge what so ever before, and by looking at your statistics, once again you still don't know enough about the game.
*****
LOL - yes I'll use kiddie speak for ya!
All I gotta say is HUH?
My stats merely show that I'm an average player who likes medium/fast tanks.
My arguments are rational, and far more useful then 'wahhh, OMG arty sux'
I'm not asking that you believe me. I'm just trying to talk.
I am attempted to reason with people, but it's the internet...and reason apparently just isn't possible.
If you guys hate arty so irrationally and so much...stop playing.
btw - my name comes from an inside joke - nothing to do with 'scarey' why don't you do a little wiki search and actually find out what a 'ghost cat' is!
Have a nice day, I've got to get back to work.
-theghostcat
- us server
LOL Lord Azaghul you kiding right?
ReplyDeletearty are bigest bullshit in this game,they camp in base alwais insible and one shoting all even if they miss,splash is enouth.Just wait after you spot red dot on minimap and after right click+left click=instant frag(s).
ReplyDeleteAnd its not all they shot fast even like heavy tank on some tear check objeck somethink with T30.
And like bonus they oneshot you but you need more then 2 hit too kill them.
Arty need reduce damage,splash,rof,aculary and limit 2per team max+return tracer or game will be still unplayeble,comom even if you are medium you have no change if they shot too you or 3-4meter they kill you if they shot around 10m away from you you survive but you are fucked,track damaged,lost modules and crew
One question Overlord: there will be options to buy a premium account for one or half year, so will we be able to transfer this premium acc. to our account on World of Warplanes or World of Battleships?
ReplyDeletei want more zero arty battles!
ReplyDeleteOverlord isnt it I'm a fAn of online games. On my Computer it says fUn of online games.
ReplyDeleteOther wise I love the way arty is in this game.
Simple arty fix
ReplyDeleteBRING BACK TRACERS !
once arty have to worry about counter battery again - esp with the splash radius of the new Tier 7 and 8 arty they will not be as much of an issue any more
Counter battery was the historical soloution to arty issues and will be the best one in game as well.
And as always i send my usual salute to the anonymous cowards that flame and rage but cannot be bothered to tell us who they are - nice troll - go bother someone who cares :)
Overlord:
ReplyDeleteOnly reason why 22% has NP with it - because at least fifth of the players are artillery. And only reason why only 15% responded that its OP or bad design, because it didn't include solution (as limiting they numbers).
Artillery is OP and its whole concept is wrong. Why? Because its shooting behind obstacles, doing massive damage every shot and shooting across whole map and on many maps, there is absolutely no defense against them! The way how you balanced them - low hp - is useless, if you cannot kill it, because is hidden on the other side of the map!
If anything, it should do same damage as any average tank on its tier. And it would be still overpowered since normal tanks cannot shoot through walls.
Stop blaming arty and turning this into a flame war. It is fine as it is once the tiers get limited and tracers get reintroduced. -.-
ReplyDeleteDespite the eager number of responses, I'm still a bit curious. Overlord, do the Russian players have any opinions concerning limits and balancing?
ReplyDeleteHello, I was vote for OP, so I'm minority:D
ReplyDeleteBut my vote was not so "exact". IMHO arty is not OP, but have far too much info from battle field.
Eg. if arty can't see enemy all info about them (in game) is based on radio communication. So why playing arty I can see not only position of enemy, but exact presentation of hull or even a turret rotation! Still, imho, arty should see only a type icon and additional updated lets say in 2-3 sec interval (as radio can truly do). This should properly balance arty role in game (assuming limited ammount of ammo). Off course its true only when arty crew can't see enemy.
@ This guy...
ReplyDeleteAnonymous said...
arty is not a big problem, its just when all tanks are gone and there are 5 arty camping in each base waiting for nothing :P
September 14, 2011 3:17 PM
Demonicus replies...
The fact that there are still 5 arty left on each team and no tanks is blatant proof that there is a problem. Anyone who says there isn't a problem is probably someone who predominantly plays arty. I play one arty from each country and one TD from each country but the rest of my garage is filled with standard tanks. I know what it is like to play arty and I also know what it is like to play regular tanks and feel as though you have to camp in one of two safe places on any given map because you fear that 5 one-shot-one-kill rounds might drop out of the sky if you even so much as peek around the corner.
Arty numbers are a problem right now and that aspect of the game needs to be regulated by putting limits on the number of arty or a weight limit for arty in the matchmaking algorithm...simple as that.
The poll was too early. Tier 5 Scouts will be out tomorrow and will change everything.
ReplyDeleteI always hope to get in a came with many arties with my leopard, but it never really happens. I am getting the feeling that u have limited the numbers of arty if a scout platoon is in the match. Or it could be just bad luck. ;)
The only reason I play a scout ist to fuck arty up. They annoy me as hell.
To all the other players: If u really hate arty: Start playing scouts.
The only reason I play arty my self is to troll. seriously. I hate arty so much that I decided to become one of them myself. To annoy others.
PS: People are talking a lot of nonsense here. There is no need to limit arty to 2, or 3. Five should be the maximum. That would still be annoying as hell but somehow playable.
People on here are generally failing the logic test.
ReplyDeleteIf they are complaining of too many arty (and according to this poll, they are) then that's only because they are failing to think logically.
If there is a battle with 5 arty per side then the odds of each players being singled out by arty fire is huge. Therefor players quickly come to hate arty in large numbers.
If however they have a battle with just one arty per side then the odds that the arty will impact them is very low.
But the fact remains that arty is still ruining someone else's fun.
Fact, arty are OP, the difference in response between the 80% who don't think its ok is in the number of games arty has singled them out.
Fix arty by changing its fundamental ability and not by restricting it. Arty is OP and broken and worse of all, fun wreckers in its current form.
@Lord Azaghul
ReplyDeleteI both agree and disagree with your points about arty; certain heavies can be forgiving in certain situations, but they must rely on the team just as much as any other element. I dont think arty is op, but there does need to be some kind of matchmaking check put in place to limit the matches where 4-5 high tier arty can play 'the god of war', as a certain dictator once said.
Also kudos to you for putting your player name out there. Ive noticed a lot of stat elitism going on lately that is definitely hurting the community, since it devalues players and their opinions based on their stats. Sure, stats will give you a general picture of a players performance, but theres no point in using that as an argument as to why YOUR argument is right. If you have time to point out how someone needs to 'L2P', you have time to properly illustrate a counter argument. Seriously, were not all children.
I voted other reason because i play WoT for the four reason, it's a fun game, online, i'm a tank buff and nothing can relax me more than a Team kill … huh wait what ? XD
ReplyDeleteI hope you guys fix the arty number
ReplyDeleteI love this game, that's why I play. But in regards to "Its a great way to relax" That's about the opposite feeling this game gives me when I play it.... ha ha!
ReplyDeleteI think the biggest impact on todays arty game- and teamplay are missing tracers. I liked playing my Hummel and trying to counter the enemy arty, while they were trying the same. It was like a sharpshooter batlle, waiting for the mistae of the error. And because 50% were succesful, arty not many played it or were careful, when revealing there position
ReplyDeleteWhen i now play with my Hummel I just drive into a nice spot and lay down my fire on the enemy, not moving, because most maps let me shoot everywhere I want. Thats just boring ...
So the first step to improve gameplay with and against arty is to reintroduce tracer (with cheatprotection of course) and let it run for a couple of weeks (or just on the testservers) and ask the community how it works. (reintroduce tracers for all tanks of course)
If theres still a lot arty and most of the community is complaining about, the second step would be to set a limitation, because even with tracer 7 high-tier-artys kill nearly everything.
PS: morgotz on the eu server
[URL=http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/143/shot004qh.jpg/][IMG]http://img143.imageshack.us/img143/2718/shot004qh.jpg[/IMG][/URL]
ReplyDeleteUploaded with [URL=http://imageshack.us]ImageShack.us[/URL]
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/143/shot004qh.jpg/
ReplyDeletecopy and paste screen shot of 8 Artillery Per side
Other Reason: I don't even know why I play anymore. My cousin got me on this game promising that we'd play often, but more often then not I'm playing by myself. I'm stuck at tier 8 because it takes forever to gain the money to get to Tier 9. And I don't want to get gold because I don't like the way you guys run the game enough to contribute to your paycheck. So, as to the reason I play? I guess right now the only reason I play is to keep in touch with the few friends I made in-game.
ReplyDelete^^^^^^^ this guys a total loser
ReplyDeleteu know that there is lot of arty cause there is lots of players that play arty?
ReplyDeletepeople, do u know how much u have to wait to get in a battle with a tier 7 spg? too much
and with a tier 8 spg, if im lucky i get 10 seconds wait, but the rule is no less than 3 minutes of wait, and regular i find myself with the 5 minutes dead wait. (and i didnt even consider if im with platoon, that will make it worst. then a tier 7/8 SPG shots like 10 shots per game (as they do) as u know lots of shots will be miss, because tank moves, or because it get misdirected to a rock or wall or roof of something that was at the side of the aim circle, then u r a tier 7/8 SPG and your fail team let 1 t54 come to u then u r dead at the minute 2 of the battle, then wait the battle to end so u again pay repair bil with almost no played time u try to join another battle, then again a maybe 2 / 3 / 4 minute wait to play , then u got luck your team dont let the meds kill u, but your team best heavy tanks hide behind the arty whole game, then come the enemy tanks and spot u, enemy arty kill u, then u need to pay again 25k credits bill just for begin dumb to try to play with arty, arty is OP? no, a good team that make their arty do their job is the OP, good spoters, good defence from spoters, and patient if u know how to use arty maybe u will win, but maybe if u get destoyed even if u won u lose 10k/15k credits.
BTW im looking foward to the medal that is give 4 destroying 5 or more artys in a single battle
How about 11 (http://img713.imageshack.us/img713/6714/shot002rx.jpg) SPG's or even 13 (http://img220.imageshack.us/img220/3651/shot001x.jpg). Sure, I was with arty in the first game, but still..
ReplyDelete"22% of players have no issues with SPGs"
ReplyDelete- 22% are SPG players, noobs and hardcore campers
Limit the number is no solution. 3 SPGs per team are too much and even 1 per team is annoying.
What genius thought SPGs would be a good idea in a tank game.
And now bringing new T5 light tanks to counter SPGs is just retarded.
Remove the stupid SPGs already.
"Thanks for the feedback, it will take time, but the issue will be addressed."
ReplyDeleteWell, time is something you don't really have. Took you 3 months of massive whining to even realize people at the forums are not just talking shit. Taking out tracers 'for a bit' and then not returning them (I have my doubts if they will be reintroduced at all) then sitting on your arses doing the n+1th useless map and the m+1th useless tank instead of looking for feedback was a terrible move.
GG wargaming!!! new map pfff, arty map........
ReplyDeleteAwesome game.. 5-8 arty/team..... fuck you.....
It's funny how people thing they can bend the poll around their opinion, twist it ab bit and then is says 99% are against spg's at all. ...or get insulting on those who voted for artys.
ReplyDeleteWhat a mature culture of comments.
I personally don't think they are op. Plenty of maps out there where you can take cover from spg's plus plenty of shots just miss by default hiting the absolut outer part of the aiming circle.
IF there is a problem with artys it's the general matchmaking, but then again you have this problem with other tanks aswell.
I more and more get the impression that spg's will allways hate the problem of "haters are going to hate". They are the greates threat for all those heavydrivers out there whom without artys would become invincible... or at least hoping they'd do.
Wonderful game.......
ReplyDeletehttp://kepkezelo.com/images/py85l06shmiw5x5ydob.jpg
16 arty!!!! 2011.09.15 12:55 minute GG wargaming!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
retard idiot!!!!!!!!
Yeah just got the fishing bay finaly and bang... 10 SPG's and game was ruined. DO SOMETHING WITH THAT BULLSHIT!!!
ReplyDeleteI think they should keep arty the way it is, and here is my reason:
ReplyDelete1. The game needs variation. Having the same kind of setup every game will in a very short period of time make battle very similar.
2. 0 arty is more broken then 5 per team.
lmfao add tracers back in and Arty will have a harder time that's why arty has become so prominent IMO because they basically cant be found any longer without someone killing them selves if you add tracers back it gives the opposing arty something to look for instead of that slow moving Maus or Is4.
ReplyDeletei love my arty and because i play it so much i know the places arty Can and Can't hit me you have to master the shield as well as the sword
Hello
ReplyDeletewhat is interresrting in this game is to fight and move.
With so much arty (3 or more per side) you just have to hide the best as you can or die fast very fast.
Arty kill tank that's a good thing but it also kill the fun of the game.
2 Arty max would be a good think you must take care of what you do but if you show yourself you will have a chance to survive mùore than 10 seconde.
Arty yes but in a reasonnable number!!!
thank's
I'd suggest a limit of 2 per side.
ReplyDeleteI'd also like to see a change in the way that the SPGs "scale up" into tier 6 and beyond, so that they're erratic all-or-nothing doomtrolls by the time they hit tier 8. Tier 5 and below, they seem fine.
"they're not", rather. Interupted in the middle of typing, lost track.
ReplyDeleteOverlord, try implementing this : max level for arty per team <=20. max number of arty < 4.
ReplyDeleteSo only 22% of people have no issues with arty, the rest of it (a very big 78%) say arty is broken in one way or another. I hope deveolopers take this into account...
ReplyDeleteFor now you should cut arty dps by 50%, and restore it WHEN you BRING BACK TRACES
ReplyDeleteI have an idea, since there will be World of Warplanes and World of Warships. Just make a World of Artilery/SPG. It seems alot of games are coming to it anyways.
ReplyDeleteI am new to this blog and missed the question, but will be following from now on.
just make max 3 spg per team (platoons)
ReplyDeleteand remove spg from city maps(ensk,himelsdorf)
or at least decrease chance of getting such map coz atm it is to high
Aventhal
I personally believe it should only be 1-2 arty per game. Anything over that and arty can totally control the game, especially with higher tier arty.
ReplyDeleteThe point is becoming moot. Due to aiming mechanics changes in the last patch, the problem of too many arti is being taken care of. Track the number and level of the arti players in all your battles over the next couple days, I think you will find that there are already fewer arti per game. No one wants to play a tank that only gets to take 3 or 4 fully aimed shots in a game.
ReplyDelete