Its either broken or the clans fighting on the Province Oslo have a really long battle. It still gives the battle time from yesterday. And this has been happening for at least two days on EU1 and EU2 server.
Dear overlord, start from here :) http://forum.worldoftanks.eu/index.php?/topic/202716-clan-wars-feedback-whats-not-working/page__st__180__pid__5474622#entry5474622
Meanwhile WG is making big mistake - http://worldoftanks.ru/ru/news/1/symbols_of_victory/
(here translation for those who do not understand Russian - http://ftr.wot-news.com/2013/08/05/symbols-of-victory-stalin-strikes-back/#more-1436 )
Honoring mass murderer is bad PR policy (except for Russia and Belorussia as we see).
One mobile phones company in my country used Lenin in commercials. After a few days they had to withdraw them, because of customers reaction.
As you want to be see as fans of Stalins oppressions and crimes, it is your free will. But prepare to be treated as "pro-bolshevik company" by many European players.
I am not going to finance company, which wants to honor tyrant. And my sympathy to WG is over. For me Stalin = Hitler.
Sure, Tukhachevsky wasn't tortured and killed and like Zinoviev or Trotsky he died because he was old (at age 44). And Khrushchev was CIA agent so this is why he described in 1956 Stalin's purges and crimes - http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/О_культе_личности_и_его_последствиях - here full text in Russian http://ru.wikisource.org/wiki/О_культе_личности_и_его_последствиях._Доклад_XX_съезду_КПСС_(Н.С._Хрущев).
And this, what Khrushchev revealed, was only a tip of the iceberg
Hahaha yes yes big lie, "denier!", all the secret documents with annihilation orders and political cleanings, the photos and videos with mass graves and executions from behind in the head and burrying them alive are all big lies, yeah and the newspapers with photos from the Holodomor are also big lies. Which are all confirmed by Gorbatshov and other high soviets, shame on u shame on u all stalinist lovers.
Both Stalin and Hitler were monstern none of them have to be worshipped!
Oh yeah and the terror was going on, NKWD, KGB and Stasi were well known for tortouring and contract murderings will the end of the soviet union against political enemies and soviet dissidents.
I have a great idea. Split the EU servers into butthurt and non butthurt.
Those that don't get butthurt by a historical inscription can carry on as normal, and the butthurt server can contain unicorns and pixies and stuff and no historical inscriptions.
Exactly, they were monsters, that it why we should never try to forget them by erasing their name from their creations. This is why we need to keep references of Stalin, and the swastika, and the rising sun, to keep reminding us of why men died. To speak someone's name is NOT to glorify them, it's to acknowledge that they existed and if the truth of their existence disturbs you, good. That means you haven't forgotten, but don't turn your personal disgust for someone into a denial that leads other to forget WHY and go down the same path as them. THIS IS WHY HISTORY IS IMPORTANT, THE GOOD, THE BAD, AND AND THE HISTORY WE WANT TO FORGET!
I'm an American, and I have my own demons: the firebombing of Tokyo, Hiroshima and Nagasaki, slavery, the Israeli Palestinian conflict; shall I go on?
Swastika is forbidden in WoT, the same like Hitlers name, SS, and even Wittmanns name. I do understand reasons why it was done and accept them. But I do not like policy "our mass murderer is cool, their mass murderer is forbidden".
Initially WG allowed all local offices to decide which inscriptions are OK and which are not. That was very good policy. All Western offices decided not to introduce inscriptions with Stalin. But Stalins lovers on Russian server were angry because of it, they asked developers for quite a long about this, so now WG ordered to introduce Stalin on all servers. It is like "how you dare to block our Stalin, you European and American scums!"
At the same time Russians were in last weeks attacking Company of Heroes 2 cause they didn't like how the game showed some aspects of Soviet army. Sega decided to withdraw the game from Russia.
Actually, I don't agree with the banning of certain symbols by other countries just because they bring up bad memories. That being said, in a country like the United states those symbols should be used in the U.S. version of the game, in fact any version of the game that isn't used in a country that directly bans those symbols. So, there's still some stuff to fix.
quote: "The reasons for banning things from the game should be crystal clear - it's forbidden if it's forbidden by law, either international or local."
how's that working out exactly?! because there are a lot of countries in Europe that has laws banning communist slogans, inscriptions, etc - want examples? Hungary, Poland ..
and there's this: http://tinyurl.com/mdg48er
also, quoting overlord again: "There is no worshipping. You are blind with your emotions." and from WG's own post: "While Josef Stalin is not an uncontroversial personality of history, and to many his conduct is seen with strong feelings and severity, his contributions to overcoming the forces of fascism threatening Europe and the world during the middle of the 20th century as well as his role as a leader in the anti-Hitler coalition" so, Stalin was the one who "vanquished" Hitler and his fascism, not the tens on millions of soviet troops - one man did it all how exactly is that not worshiping ?!?! cult of personality rings any bells
And here it goes, epic shitstorm http://forum.worldoftanks.eu/index.php?/topic/279380-historical-content-in-world-of-tanks/#top
Huge PR fail, even more players not liking company and even less players ready to defend it or explain policies and decisions (I will now surely think twice before doing such things). Your bosses totally do not understand West. Very sad because I like this game, or maybe liked, I am not sure yet.
west?!?!?! sorry mate, but you are gravely mistaking I live in a ex-communist country, Romania is a S-E European country Hungary is Central European, same Poland
Europe, Central Europe, Baltic region is not "the west" we lived communism, not "the west" - the whole fucking Eastern Bloc
Yeah, EU and NA servers are only for ex-communist countries, lol. Also maybe you missed that, but communism ended in the countries you mention in 1989, so 24 years ago. And now they are all in NATO and EU. This is the West. Specially for Russians.
Also Hungary or Poland were always much more western then eastern. Communism was just a short time in their history.
snapping fingers and communism ended .. just like that or is it? take Belarus for example - Alexander Lukashenko is "president" since 1994 and declares himself as "independent" although he's pro soviet (yep, I said right .. pro soviet)
Russia - they have, yet again, Putin as president and he's not shy with his pro-soviet view
communism did not die just because Soviet Union disbanded
are we still speaking of ex-Eastern Block, about "former" USSR?
those countries, those leaders live here with us on Earth, some of us are closer than others to them they do not live in a bubble, their actions aren't without consequences .. globally
Even assholes do SOME good, Hitler brought a starving country out of the worst economic depression in history.
That being said, I hold Stalin is worse light than even Hitler. A lot of the bad that came out of he 1917 Russian Revolution can be traced back to Stalin, chiefly the Red Torror, a series of executions proposed to Lenin by Stalin after an assassination attempt on Lenin. The death toll range on the Red Terror is wide because of the poor population records taken at the time, but they average around 500,000. When Lenin suffered a stroke and went into retirement, Stalin took the reins almost unchecked. In Lenin's letters he criticized Stalin's political actions and even asked for him to be removed from power. We all know what came of that. In the next 30 years Stalin executed, or worked to death, more Russians than those that actually died from WW2. And if you think that's bad you should check out Mao.
"Even assholes do SOME good, Hitler brought a starving country out of the worst economic depression in history."
It is disputable. I had read not so long ago some article, which claimed that his economic policy was also huge disaster. He made short leaved prosperity, but after a few years he needed war to finance his "economical miracle". Author claimed that if not the war Hitler would be remembered as someone who totally ruined German budget.
I don't have and even do not remember website. Also it wasn't in English :) But even Wikipedia mentions this financial problems ". Between 1933 and 1939, the total revenue was 62 billion marks, whereas expenditure (at times made up to 60% by rearmament costs) exceeded 101 billion, thus creating a huge deficit and national debt (reaching 38 billion marks in 1939).
Stalin IS a great historical figure, Roosevelt IS a great historical figure, Hitler IS a great historical figure, Gandhi IS a great historical figure. My point: Great historical figure =/= good human being, it just means important.
it doesn´t matter that they had them, german tanks surely had inscriptions glorifying the german side of the war. WG argues they won´t use those because Nazi = bad and its forbidden by law to display them. Many people on EU server argue the same way, communism = bad. Some EU countries even banned that kind of sovjet propaganda. The EU server can use the same arguments against nazi and sovjet propaganda as WG uses against nazi propaganda.
@coldt what kind of sub-human are you? putting Stalin and Hitler on the "great historical figures", on the same level as Gandhi
those two mutherfuckers killed tens of millions of humans just because, and yet, Gandhi was instrumental in gaining independence for India by being non-violent and promoting non-violence
Gandhi is a great historical figure, Staling and Hitler are just stains of history
btw one of our ads (with no illegal stuff) was banned in Germany because they thought it was inappropriate to picture tanks that way. They do prefer to be silent about this.
I know, I've heard about that, it's almost reprehensible. Both Germans and Russians would like people to forget a few things because those things are shameful and unsavory. That's why we should never forget. If you fail to remember the past you are doomed to repeat it.
This is much of the reason why I was taught about things like slavery and Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the 5th grade, in school. I was 10 so they didn't go into the gory details, they wait till 10th or 11th grade to do that, but they at least mentioned them and put them in context.
no, just showing my unhappiness about Wargamings behaviour towards its customer base in Europe. You have repeatedly shown that you don´t care for us. An european player playing on RU-servers and complaining about something would get the answer don´t play on RU-server if you don´t like that and that. Instead russian players on EU-server get told ok you want that you can get it even if that is against the wishes of EU-players.
He'll never answer a question so ignorant and unfairly pointed. If he says yes he'd denying the Stalin was a brutal dictator, if he says no he'd denying that Stalin lead his country to victory against Hitler and saved all of Russia from an even worse fate than his own rule. Do you have any idea what it was like on the eastern front? You wana know what the Nazi's did to survivors? They straight up killed the men, then they raped the women and children, then they killed them to. That would have happened to all of Russia had Stalin's emergency orders not held back the German army until winter. Even still, 27 million Russian died. How many would it have been if the German's had taken the country, 50 million, 100 million?
No, sir. You don't get an answer from overlord. You don't deserve one, you ignorant son of a bitch.
From 2009: MOSCOW — Russia’s president, Dmitri A. Medvedev, warned Friday that Russians had lost their sense of horror over Stalin’s purges, and called for the construction of museums and memorial centers devoted to the atrocities, as well as further efforts to unearth and identify the dead.
Wow overlord, My sympathies. You seem to be absorbing a lot of hate lately on this blog. I might be a little whiny about losing my t50-2 but that would really be my only complaint. As for the Stalin thing, If people are getting offended by it, that's their choice to do so.
It was much worse in late 2011, when people were angry with waiting for M103-T34 change and some other things.
And I show no hate, I only show my disappointment and negative opinion about WG behaviour in this case. In many other cases I was usually defending WG.
Whole Stalin case caused that WG from liked company became for me only neutral, like dozens others. And I started to look for other games in which I can spend money. I think it is fair to inform developers in civilized way about effects of their decisions. And I prefer to do it here, then on EU forum cause as we see EU office opinion means nothing for Minsk.
I can understand why russians are proud of winning the war with their allies (thats justified), and i can see that this victory is to some extend seen as an achievment that Stalin made possible. So, nobody has a problem with russian people to be proud about that. But letting paroles and obeisances stay in a videogame that glorify a dictator, tyrann and mass murderer who commanded millions to death and torture is for sure not the right way to go.
If you guys over in russia cant see that, well, what can i say more. I lost a lot of respect for you Overlord, when this is okay or good for you.
sincerely in game i dont care for inscriptions, dont buy them, dont read them. In my opinion people are overreacting but it can be understood. You can't ban blue from a rainbow and then maintain orange because is closer to red. You brought it on yourselves WG. At the same time you give arguments to the people who say that, to WG, EU servers are meant to be an appendix/extension of RU kingdom. Pixeled Imperialism at its best.
I will keep playing your game, but i'll do that only because i never spent a cent on it (yet have several tier 10 and 9 and even a premium tank).
P.S.: Let go of planes P.S.2: Captcha still sucks P.S.3: Now, your updater doesn't freeze my computer.
Interesting Stalin debate. Many of us in the west view Stalin and the Soviet communistparty at the time as equally evil as Hitler. So do I.
But we can still honor and respect the Soviet fight against the nazis, i.e. the Soviet policy after 1941. We can honor the great work of the Red Army. To honor that work is another thing.
The role of the Soviet Red Army in the fight to defeat Hitler and the nazis are underestimated in the west, and people have bad knowledge about it.
Be careful with the Stalin thing if you want to be a big company in the west and the USA. Many would react to it as you, I am sure, react against Hitler. Bad PR you know... Keep Stalin-inscrptions if you like, that is your decison, but make sure that WG has a plan how to handle this (if you want to be ig in the USA and keep growning in Europe).
The combination with the general racism against poles by players the pro-Stalin inscriptions is a bit... awkward!
I think that it would be naive to underestimate the role played by the red army in WW2. But with or without Stalin, the generals, the commanders, and so on, of the red army managed to do their job. They would have done the job even without Stalin, probably with less loss of life. Acting in an opposite way, Hitler enforced ridiculous decisions and oposed his experienced generals, thus the epic fails (just like wg not listening to players). So in my opinion the only good job that Stalin made was to let millitary strategy to the professionals. The entire merit of defeating the germans was of the military, the support they got from their allies and of course the russian weather.
Stalin only delayed the victory: the purging in the army as an example, military resources used to kill civilians instead of the enemy soldiers, not helping in the uprising of Prague until the the uprising was defeated and not allowing the americans to assist the uprisng of Prague and the examples could continue.
Probably Hitler helped more than Stalin to bring the war to an end because his stupid decisions, as Churchill also said.
As a conclusion the war was won by the professional soldiers who were allowed to use their knowledge.
So Overlord, maybe for you its to late, but for the rest I still have hope in understanding history.
Stalin is one of the aggressors that caused the Second World War. His war against Finland, invasion of Rumania-Bessarabia and the Baltic states combined with his senseless alliance with Nazi- Germany and invasion of Poland put the Western Allies in a bad position causing the fall of Western Europe. Here Stalin had counted on a prolonged war like that in 1914-18. The failure of this placed the Germans 5km from the Kremlin and an inch from destroying the USSR. These crimes alone condemns him as one of the greatest traitors of Russia and former States of the USSR. It's easy to forget this and instead focus on the extremely costly defeat of Hitler at the expense of 30million dead.
Seriously, I'm an American who payed attention in history class. Now, Stalin was bad, but too many people think he's like the living embodiment of Satan or something.
Here's what you SHOULD know about the Cold War. Russia had just seen 2 wars, within a 30 year period, and Russia took the brunt of both of them. In WW1 they lost over 3 million people, the highest of all the Entente powers, then in WW2, close to 30 million. After that, they didn't want to see ANYTHING like that happen again, so they started to make a buffer zone between them and the rest of the world that, honestly, looked like they were out to get them. That's where you see the formation of the U.S.S.R. It was an attempt to create a buffer zone, so that in case of ANOTHER invasion Russia would have more time to mobilize their army before the enemy was knocking at their door.
To bolster their defenses, Russia started to build up its military. Then, you end up getting into this cycle of mutual fear. The western powers were affraid of the eastern's military build up and started to build up themselves. Then Russia sees this and fears invasion, with every right. Every previous military buildup this century ended with millions of Russians dead. It was all a GIANT overreaction brought on by mutual paranoia and hawkish politicians.
"How terrible..."
ReplyDeleteNow we know why the CW map on EU server is still broken. Decisions, ain't got time for those.
ReplyDeleteBroken how exactly?
DeleteIts either broken or the clans fighting on the Province Oslo have a really long battle. It still gives the battle time from yesterday. And this has been happening for at least two days on EU1 and EU2 server.
DeleteAlso on Brandenburg still fighting and the day before yesterday on Bryansk region.
DeleteAlso from what ive read there are landings which keeps crashing and special battles that dont come up.
Our EU team is being as helpfull as ever again and dont even read the common "problems with CW" thread.
Dear overlord, start from here :) http://forum.worldoftanks.eu/index.php?/topic/202716-clan-wars-feedback-whats-not-working/page__st__180__pid__5474622#entry5474622
DeleteUpdate. Registered a bug for this.
DeleteHmm.. I feel snubbed, where's my Union Flag?
ReplyDeleteThere are flags of countries we have got offices in. Some flags however are missing.
DeleteGood pic of SerB :P
ReplyDeleteMeanwhile WG is making big mistake - http://worldoftanks.ru/ru/news/1/symbols_of_victory/
ReplyDelete(here translation for those who do not understand Russian - http://ftr.wot-news.com/2013/08/05/symbols-of-victory-stalin-strikes-back/#more-1436 )
Honoring mass murderer is bad PR policy (except for Russia and Belorussia as we see).
One mobile phones company in my country used Lenin in commercials. After a few days they had to withdraw them, because of customers reaction.
As you want to be see as fans of Stalins oppressions and crimes, it is your free will. But prepare to be treated as "pro-bolshevik company" by many European players.
I am not going to finance company, which wants to honor tyrant. And my sympathy to WG is over. For me Stalin = Hitler.
That's your choice and I respect it.
Delete"...of Stalins oppressions and crimes..."-It's The Big Lie, it live on West only in present time.
Delete@ ruslan63
DeleteSure, Tukhachevsky wasn't tortured and killed and like Zinoviev or Trotsky he died because he was old (at age 44). And Khrushchev was CIA agent so this is why he described in 1956 Stalin's purges and crimes - http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/О_культе_личности_и_его_последствиях - here full text in Russian http://ru.wikisource.org/wiki/О_культе_личности_и_его_последствиях._Доклад_XX_съезду_КПСС_(Н.С._Хрущев).
And this, what Khrushchev revealed, was only a tip of the iceberg
Beware! Lot of sarcasm here!
Hahaha yes yes big lie, "denier!", all the secret documents with annihilation orders and political cleanings, the photos and videos with mass graves and executions from behind in the head and burrying them alive are all big lies, yeah and the newspapers with photos from the Holodomor are also big lies.
DeleteWhich are all confirmed by Gorbatshov and other high soviets, shame on u shame on u all stalinist lovers.
Both Stalin and Hitler were monstern none of them have to be worshipped!
Oh yeah and the terror was going on, NKWD, KGB and Stasi were well known for tortouring and contract murderings will the end of the soviet union against political enemies and soviet dissidents.
DeleteThere is no worshipping. You are blind with your emotions.
DeleteI have a great idea. Split the EU servers into butthurt and non butthurt.
DeleteThose that don't get butthurt by a historical inscription can carry on as normal, and the butthurt server can contain unicorns and pixies and stuff and no historical inscriptions.
There you go Overlord.. give us a job!
Exactly, they were monsters, that it why we should never try to forget them by erasing their name from their creations. This is why we need to keep references of Stalin, and the swastika, and the rising sun, to keep reminding us of why men died. To speak someone's name is NOT to glorify them, it's to acknowledge that they existed and if the truth of their existence disturbs you, good. That means you haven't forgotten, but don't turn your personal disgust for someone into a denial that leads other to forget WHY and go down the same path as them. THIS IS WHY HISTORY IS IMPORTANT, THE GOOD, THE BAD, AND AND THE HISTORY WE WANT TO FORGET!
DeleteI'm an American, and I have my own demons: the firebombing of Tokyo, Hiroshima and Nagasaki, slavery, the Israeli Palestinian conflict; shall I go on?
@Coldt
DeleteSwastika is forbidden in WoT, the same like Hitlers name, SS, and even Wittmanns name. I do understand reasons why it was done and accept them. But I do not like policy "our mass murderer is cool, their mass murderer is forbidden".
Initially WG allowed all local offices to decide which inscriptions are OK and which are not. That was very good policy. All Western offices decided not to introduce inscriptions with Stalin. But Stalins lovers on Russian server were angry because of it, they asked developers for quite a long about this, so now WG ordered to introduce Stalin on all servers. It is like "how you dare to block our Stalin, you European and American scums!"
At the same time Russians were in last weeks attacking Company of Heroes 2 cause they didn't like how the game showed some aspects of Soviet army. Sega decided to withdraw the game from Russia.
Coldt made some good points above.
DeleteThe reasons for banning things from the game should be crystal clear - it's forbidden if it's forbidden by law, either international or local.
Personal attitude doesn't count.
Actually, you may, as you are making historical games, to ask for permission in using of swastika, inscriptions and names.....
DeleteActually, I don't agree with the banning of certain symbols by other countries just because they bring up bad memories. That being said, in a country like the United states those symbols should be used in the U.S. version of the game, in fact any version of the game that isn't used in a country that directly bans those symbols. So, there's still some stuff to fix.
Deletequote: "The reasons for banning things from the game should be crystal clear - it's forbidden if it's forbidden by law, either international or local."
Deletehow's that working out exactly?! because there are a lot of countries in Europe that has laws banning communist slogans, inscriptions, etc - want examples? Hungary, Poland ..
and there's this: http://tinyurl.com/mdg48er
also, quoting overlord again:
"There is no worshipping. You are blind with your emotions."
and from WG's own post: "While Josef Stalin is not an uncontroversial personality of history, and to many his conduct is seen with strong feelings and severity, his contributions to overcoming the forces of fascism threatening Europe and the world during the middle of the 20th century as well as his role as a leader in the anti-Hitler coalition"
so, Stalin was the one who "vanquished" Hitler and his fascism, not the tens on millions of soviet troops - one man did it all
how exactly is that not worshiping ?!?! cult of personality rings any bells
And here it goes, epic shitstorm http://forum.worldoftanks.eu/index.php?/topic/279380-historical-content-in-world-of-tanks/#top
DeleteHuge PR fail, even more players not liking company and even less players ready to defend it or explain policies and decisions (I will now surely think twice before doing such things). Your bosses totally do not understand West. Very sad because I like this game, or maybe liked, I am not sure yet.
west?!?!?!
Deletesorry mate, but you are gravely mistaking
I live in a ex-communist country, Romania is a S-E European country
Hungary is Central European, same Poland
Europe, Central Europe, Baltic region is not "the west"
we lived communism, not "the west" - the whole fucking Eastern Bloc
Yeah, EU and NA servers are only for ex-communist countries, lol. Also maybe you missed that, but communism ended in the countries you mention in 1989, so 24 years ago. And now they are all in NATO and EU. This is the West. Specially for Russians.
DeleteAlso Hungary or Poland were always much more western then eastern. Communism was just a short time in their history.
snapping fingers and communism ended .. just like that
Deleteor is it? take Belarus for example - Alexander Lukashenko is "president" since 1994 and declares himself as "independent" although he's pro soviet (yep, I said right .. pro soviet)
Russia - they have, yet again, Putin as president and he's not shy with his pro-soviet view
communism did not die just because Soviet Union disbanded
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteWas I writing that it ended in Belarus and Russia? No. We were talking abut Romania, Hungary, Poland and Baltic states.
Deleteare we still speaking of ex-Eastern Block, about "former" USSR?
Deletethose countries, those leaders live here with us on Earth, some of us are closer than others to them
they do not live in a bubble, their actions aren't without consequences .. globally
I was writing nothing about former USSR. I think you should take more care about controlling what is discussed. End of topic
DeleteOverlord, just a quick question. Do you believe Stalin is a hero?
ReplyDeleteI believe he is a great historic figure.
DeleteEven assholes do SOME good, Hitler brought a starving country out of the worst economic depression in history.
DeleteThat being said, I hold Stalin is worse light than even Hitler. A lot of the bad that came out of he 1917 Russian Revolution can be traced back to Stalin, chiefly the Red Torror, a series of executions proposed to Lenin by Stalin after an assassination attempt on Lenin. The death toll range on the Red Terror is wide because of the poor population records taken at the time, but they average around 500,000. When Lenin suffered a stroke and went into retirement, Stalin took the reins almost unchecked. In Lenin's letters he criticized Stalin's political actions and even asked for him to be removed from power. We all know what came of that. In the next 30 years Stalin executed, or worked to death, more Russians than those that actually died from WW2. And if you think that's bad you should check out Mao.
"Even assholes do SOME good, Hitler brought a starving country out of the worst economic depression in history."
DeleteIt is disputable. I had read not so long ago some article, which claimed that his economic policy was also huge disaster. He made short leaved prosperity, but after a few years he needed war to finance his "economical miracle". Author claimed that if not the war Hitler would be remembered as someone who totally ruined German budget.
Link?
DeleteI don't have and even do not remember website. Also it wasn't in English :) But even Wikipedia mentions this financial problems ". Between 1933 and 1939, the total revenue was 62 billion marks, whereas expenditure (at times made up to 60% by rearmament costs) exceeded 101 billion, thus creating a huge deficit and national debt (reaching 38 billion marks in 1939).
Deletenote how he said "great historic figure" and not just historic figure?
Deleteaccording to his fucked up classification, Mao Zedong killed roughly 70-80 million people, so, he should be the greatest historical figure
Overlord, why do you ignore that Stalin also was a dictator and murderous tyrant who killed millions of people?
DeleteStalin IS a great historical figure, Roosevelt IS a great historical figure, Hitler IS a great historical figure, Gandhi IS a great historical figure. My point: Great historical figure =/= good human being, it just means important.
DeleteFrankyK, why do you ignore that Russian tanks actually had Stalin's name written on them?
Delete@Coldt
Deleteit doesn´t matter that they had them, german tanks surely had inscriptions glorifying the german side of the war. WG argues they won´t use those because Nazi = bad and its forbidden by law to display them.
Many people on EU server argue the same way, communism = bad. Some EU countries even banned that kind of sovjet propaganda. The EU server can use the same arguments against nazi and sovjet propaganda as WG uses against nazi propaganda.
@coldt what kind of sub-human are you?
Deleteputting Stalin and Hitler on the "great historical figures", on the same level as Gandhi
those two mutherfuckers killed tens of millions of humans just because, and yet, Gandhi was instrumental in gaining independence for India by being non-violent and promoting non-violence
Gandhi is a great historical figure, Staling and Hitler are just stains of history
You fail to understand the meaning of great. Go read a dictionary.
DeleteLol, when I can destroy all arguements with 12 words, how easy.
DeleteNow I am going to challenge myself with only twelve word answers.
DeleteI pity you
DeleteI pity you, you deny history by being blinded by your feelings.
DeleteIn Germany there is growing pro Naziism, they don't talk about Nazis.
DeleteRussia is seeing similar problems, they need more informative history in school.
DeleteFrankyK,
DeleteI don't ignore that - just don't emphasise the fact.
Coldt,
Deletebtw one of our ads (with no illegal stuff) was banned in Germany because they thought it was inappropriate to picture tanks that way. They do prefer to be silent about this.
Overlord,
DeleteI know, I've heard about that, it's almost reprehensible. Both Germans and Russians would like people to forget a few things because those things are shameful and unsavory. That's why we should never forget. If you fail to remember the past you are doomed to repeat it.
This is much of the reason why I was taught about things like slavery and Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the 5th grade, in school. I was 10 so they didn't go into the gory details, they wait till 10th or 11th grade to do that, but they at least mentioned them and put them in context.
I just realized, that was not twelve words. Oh well, I tried.
Deletewell, seems like Wargaming doesn´t want my money anymore...
ReplyDeleteBlackmailing, huh? )
Deleteno, just showing my unhappiness about Wargamings behaviour towards its customer base in Europe. You have repeatedly shown that you don´t care for us.
DeleteAn european player playing on RU-servers and complaining about something would get the answer don´t play on RU-server if you don´t like that and that. Instead russian players on EU-server get told ok you want that you can get it even if that is against the wishes of EU-players.
OVERLORD you failed miserably at WOLCOT question. you have lost my respect.
ReplyDeleteI imagine you standing up and giving a salute when saying "great historic figure".
truly LAME!
I am curious what kind of reception you and your coleagues will receive around Europe from now on. Maybe you will have enough material for a blog.
I used sarcasm in case you did't notice that, because I dont think you are all that brainy anymore.....
Lame word twisting indeed.
DeleteJust give a straight answer so we wont have any "word twisting".
DeleteIs Stalin a hero to you?
yes or no?
Do you really expect to get a simple answer about one of the most complex political figures in history?
DeleteI want an answer from overlord
DeleteHe'll never answer a question so ignorant and unfairly pointed. If he says yes he'd denying the Stalin was a brutal dictator, if he says no he'd denying that Stalin lead his country to victory against Hitler and saved all of Russia from an even worse fate than his own rule. Do you have any idea what it was like on the eastern front? You wana know what the Nazi's did to survivors? They straight up killed the men, then they raped the women and children, then they killed them to. That would have happened to all of Russia had Stalin's emergency orders not held back the German army until winter. Even still, 27 million Russian died. How many would it have been if the German's had taken the country, 50 million, 100 million?
DeleteNo, sir. You don't get an answer from overlord. You don't deserve one, you ignorant son of a bitch.
From 2009: MOSCOW — Russia’s president, Dmitri A. Medvedev, warned Friday that Russians had lost their sense of horror over Stalin’s purges, and called for the construction of museums and memorial centers devoted to the atrocities, as well as further efforts to unearth and identify the dead.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/31/world/europe/31russia.html?_r=0
It's a loosing battle WG has started in regards to Stalin. Can't understand why you want to alienate so many players....
You most likely overestimate the impact of this. No big drama.
Deleteand I think you underestimate the impact of this ;)
DeleteThat's who is responsible for the most crucial decisions in WG.
ReplyDeleteYa know that doesn't surprise me either I was wandering who was the most incompetent person at WG making all of these stupid decisions of late!
Wow overlord, My sympathies. You seem to be absorbing a lot of hate lately on this blog. I might be a little whiny about losing my t50-2 but that would really be my only complaint. As for the Stalin thing, If people are getting offended by it, that's their choice to do so.
ReplyDeleteIt was much worse in late 2011, when people were angry with waiting for M103-T34 change and some other things.
DeleteAnd I show no hate, I only show my disappointment and negative opinion about WG behaviour in this case. In many other cases I was usually defending WG.
Whole Stalin case caused that WG from liked company became for me only neutral, like dozens others. And I started to look for other games in which I can spend money. I think it is fair to inform developers in civilized way about effects of their decisions. And I prefer to do it here, then on EU forum cause as we see EU office opinion means nothing for Minsk.
I can understand why russians are proud of winning the war with their allies (thats justified), and i can see that this victory is to some extend seen as an achievment that Stalin made possible. So, nobody has a problem with russian people to be proud about that. But letting paroles and obeisances stay in a videogame that glorify a dictator, tyrann and mass murderer who commanded millions to death and torture is for sure not the right way to go.
ReplyDeleteIf you guys over in russia cant see that, well, what can i say more.
I lost a lot of respect for you Overlord, when this is okay or good for you.
Hi,
ReplyDeletesincerely in game i dont care for inscriptions, dont buy them, dont read them. In my opinion people are overreacting but it can be understood. You can't ban blue from a rainbow and then maintain orange because is closer to red. You brought it on yourselves WG. At the same time you give arguments to the people who say that, to WG, EU servers are meant to be an appendix/extension of RU kingdom. Pixeled Imperialism at its best.
I will keep playing your game, but i'll do that only because i never spent a cent on it (yet have several tier 10 and 9 and even a premium tank).
P.S.: Let go of planes
P.S.2: Captcha still sucks
P.S.3: Now, your updater doesn't freeze my computer.
Interesting Stalin debate. Many of us in the west view Stalin and the Soviet communistparty at the time as equally evil as Hitler. So do I.
ReplyDeleteBut we can still honor and respect the Soviet fight against the nazis, i.e. the Soviet policy after 1941. We can honor the great work of the Red Army. To honor that work is another thing.
The role of the Soviet Red Army in the fight to defeat Hitler and the nazis are underestimated in the west, and people have bad knowledge about it.
Be careful with the Stalin thing if you want to be a big company in the west and the USA. Many would react to it as you, I am sure, react against Hitler. Bad PR you know... Keep Stalin-inscrptions if you like, that is your decison, but make sure that WG has a plan how to handle this (if you want to be ig in the USA and keep growning in Europe).
The combination with the general racism against poles by players the pro-Stalin inscriptions is a bit... awkward!
I think that it would be naive to underestimate the role played by the red army in WW2. But with or without Stalin, the generals, the commanders, and so on, of the red army managed to do their job.
ReplyDeleteThey would have done the job even without Stalin, probably with less loss of life.
Acting in an opposite way, Hitler enforced ridiculous decisions and oposed his experienced generals, thus the epic fails (just like wg not listening to players).
So in my opinion the only good job that Stalin made was to let millitary strategy to the professionals. The entire merit of defeating the germans was of the military, the support they got from their allies and of course the russian weather.
Stalin only delayed the victory: the purging in the army as an example, military resources used to kill civilians instead of the enemy soldiers, not helping in the uprising of Prague until the the uprising was defeated and not allowing the americans to assist the uprisng of Prague and the examples could continue.
Probably Hitler helped more than Stalin to bring the war to an end because his stupid decisions, as Churchill also said.
As a conclusion the war was won by the professional soldiers who were allowed to use their knowledge.
So Overlord, maybe for you its to late, but for the rest I still have hope in understanding history.
Stalin is one of the aggressors that caused the Second World War. His war against Finland, invasion of Rumania-Bessarabia and the Baltic states combined with his senseless alliance with Nazi- Germany and invasion of Poland put the Western Allies in a bad position causing the fall of Western Europe. Here Stalin had counted on a prolonged war like that in 1914-18. The failure of this placed the Germans 5km from the Kremlin and an inch from destroying the USSR. These crimes alone condemns him as one of the greatest traitors of Russia and former States of the USSR. It's easy to forget this and instead focus on the extremely costly defeat of Hitler at the expense of 30million dead.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteSeriously, I'm an American who payed attention in history class. Now, Stalin was bad, but too many people think he's like the living embodiment of Satan or something.
DeleteHere's what you SHOULD know about the Cold War. Russia had just seen 2 wars, within a 30 year period, and Russia took the brunt of both of them. In WW1 they lost over 3 million people, the highest of all the Entente powers, then in WW2, close to 30 million. After that, they didn't want to see ANYTHING like that happen again, so they started to make a buffer zone between them and the rest of the world that, honestly, looked like they were out to get them. That's where you see the formation of the U.S.S.R. It was an attempt to create a buffer zone, so that in case of ANOTHER invasion Russia would have more time to mobilize their army before the enemy was knocking at their door.
To bolster their defenses, Russia started to build up its military. Then, you end up getting into this cycle of mutual fear. The western powers were affraid of the eastern's military build up and started to build up themselves. Then Russia sees this and fears invasion, with every right. Every previous military buildup this century ended with millions of Russians dead. It was all a GIANT overreaction brought on by mutual paranoia and hawkish politicians.